The Trouble with Normal follows the lives of four men and their therapist, as they try to face the fears of the world while living in crazy New York. Bob, the most normal one, is just trying to get some help with how to handle is personal life. Zack is Bob's new neighbor and thinks he's constantly being watched and that the world is after him. Stansfield is a very insecure mailman, who finds himself constantly wanting to please people. And Max is the shyest of them all, but all he really wants is a friendly shoulder to rely on. Claire, their therapist, tries to not be driven crazy with this group. She is supposed to be their advisor, but most of the times she is the one who is advised, as the guys keep nosing themselves into her life.